Question

I know that serializing an object is (to my knowledge) the only way to effectively deep-copy an object (as long as it isn’t stateful like IO and whatnot), but is one way particularly more efficient than another?

For example, since I’m using Rails, I could always use ActiveSupport::JSON, to_xml – and from what I can tell marshalling the object is one of the most accepted ways to do this. I’d expect that marshalling is probably the most efficient of these since it’s a Ruby internal, but am I missing anything?

Edit: note that its implementation is something I already have covered – I don’t want to replace existing shallow copy methods (like dup and clone), so I’ll just end up likely adding Object::deep_copy, the result of which being whichever of the above methods (or any suggestions you have 🙂 that has the least overhead.

Answer 1

I was wondering the same thing, so I benchmarked a few different techniques against each other. I was primarily concerned with Arrays and Hashes – I didn’t test any complex objects. Perhaps unsurprisingly, a custom deep-clone implementation proved to be the fastest. If you are looking for quick and easy implementation, Marshal appears to be the way to go.

I also benchmarked an XML solution with Rails 3.0.7, not shown below. It was much, much slower, ~10 seconds for only 1000 iterations (the solutions below all ran 10,000 times for the benchmark).

Two notes regarding my JSON solution. First, I used the C variant, version 1.4.3. Second, it doesn’t actually work 100%, as symbols will be converted to Strings.

This was all run with ruby 1.9.2p180.

#!/usr/bin/env ruby
require 'benchmark'
require 'yaml'
require 'json/ext'
require 'msgpack'

def dc1(value)
  Marshal.load(Marshal.dump(value))
end

def dc2(value)
  YAML.load(YAML.dump(value))
end

def dc3(value)
  JSON.load(JSON.dump(value))
end

def dc4(value)
  if value.is_a?(Hash)
    result = value.clone
    value.each{|k, v| result[k] = dc4(v)}
    result
  elsif value.is_a?(Array)
    result = value.clone
    result.clear
    value.each{|v| result << dc4(v)}
    result
  else
    value
  end
end

def dc5(value)
  MessagePack.unpack(value.to_msgpack)
end

value = {'a' => {:x => [1, [nil, 'b'], {'a' => 1}]}, 'b' => ['z']}

Benchmark.bm do |x|
  iterations = 10000
  x.report {iterations.times {dc1(value)}}
  x.report {iterations.times {dc2(value)}}
  x.report {iterations.times {dc3(value)}}
  x.report {iterations.times {dc4(value)}}
  x.report {iterations.times {dc5(value)}}
end

results in:

user       system     total       real
0.230000   0.000000   0.230000 (  0.239257)  (Marshal)
3.240000   0.030000   3.270000 (  3.262255)  (YAML) 
0.590000   0.010000   0.600000 (  0.601693)  (JSON)
0.060000   0.000000   0.060000 (  0.067661)  (Custom)
0.090000   0.010000   0.100000 (  0.097705)  (MessagePack)