Question

I want to create a web service hosted in Windows Azure. The clients will upload files for processing, the cloud will process those files, produce resulting files, the client will download them.

I guess I’ll use web roles for handling HTTP requests and worker roles for actual processing and something like Azure Queue or Azure Table Storage for tracking requests. Let’s pretend it’ll be Azure Table Storage – one “request” record per user uploaded file.

A major design problem is processing a single file can take anywhere from one second to say ten hours.

So I expect the following case: a worker role is started, gets to Azure Table Storage, finds a request marked “ready for processing”, marks it “is being processed”, starts actual processing. Normally it would process the file and mark the request “processed”, but what if it dies unexpectedly?

Unless I take care of it the request will remain in “is being processed” state forever.

How do I track requests that are marked “is being processed” but abandoned? What mechanism in Windows Azure would be most convenient for that?

Answer 1

I believe this problem is non technology specific.
Since your processing jobs are long running, I suggest these jobs should report their progress during execution. In this way a job which has not reported progress for a substantial substantial duration becomes a clear candidate for cleanup and then can be restarted on another worker role.
How you record progress and do job swapping is upto you. One approach is to use database as recording mechanism and creating an agent worker process that pings the job progress table. In case the worker process determines any problems it can take corrective actions.

Other approach would be to associate the worker role identification with the long running process. The worker roles can communicate their health status using some sort of heart beat.
Had the jobs not been long running you could have flagged the start time of job instead on status flag and could have used the timeout mechanism to determine whether the processing has failed.