Question

Some time ago I observed a few people trying to start an open source project. About a week after the project started it more or less completely dissolved, partly due to issues with how the project itself was managed.

The ideas behind the project were however very well thought and a lot of people are still interested in seeing it realized. So far no one have made any serious attempt to recreate it but a few of us are thinking about doing so. Of course we don’t want the project to end the same way it did last time.

Now to my question. How should one start a successful open source project, where successful is defined as “the project does not die unless no one is no longer interested in the software itself anymore?”

Answer 1

Nice question, though it’s more worthy of a book than a simple article, IMHO. And I hope it comes as no surprise that most of the best advice is social, not technical.

Here are some observations in no particular order:

• Don’t make a big infrastructure investment up front Unless you’re already an Apache committer (or somesuch), don’t shop around for a sponsoring organization or host your own servers, etc. Get up on GitHub in 5 minutes and don’t look back. Put your energy in features.
• Lower the barrier for entry Don’t make potential contributors jump through hoops or undergo a background check before you’ll listen to their ideas. Open source projects are networked economies… you need the energy of others. Even misguided activity is better than no activity on your project. You can always steer the codebase in a better direction later.
• Minimize custom code Don’t write a custom logging tool or XML parsing API… there are open source implementations that are (1) good enough, (2) better maintained, and (3) better than yours will become anyway. The more energy you can focus on your core problem, the better.
• Live on the edge People and organizations will only invest in improving your project if they will directly benefit. Eat your own dogfood. Create dependencies in your other projects (like with your employer) on your open source project, even if it isn’t “perfect” yet. (Hint: software projects are never perfect, they’re either works-in-progress or dead.)