Question

After reading:

• When do you use POST and when do you use GET?
• Mixing GET with POST – is it a bad practice?

I understand, that GET is used to retrieve a page without changing the server and POST is used for things (insert, update, delete), that change the server.

Now I have written a page which is called with a GET request with parameter StationNr set. The user can fill a form and makes a POST request to the same page with parameter Filter set. But I don’t want to miss the parameter StationNr thus I thought I give it into a hidden input field. But then the parameter StationNr is either in the $_GET variable (first call) or in the $_POST variable (second call). I can do something like:

if (isset($_GET['StationNr']))
    $snr = $_GET['StationNr'];
else if (isset($_POST['StationNr']))
    $nr = $_POST['StationNr'];

But I don’t like this. Also I don’t want to use $_REQUEST['StationNr'] because of: When and why should $_REQUEST be used instead of $_GET / $_POST / $_COOKIE?

I think this is a common issue but I haven’t faced it yet because I’m a beginner in writing php pages. How did you solve this problem?

Thanks!

Answer 1

Although you can use ?foo=bar to push GET values in a POST request, I’d suggest checking the request method instead:

if($_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] == 'POST') { ... }