Question

As a ruby newbie, I was wondering, will gems ever conflict with eachother? For example, if 2 gems overrode the << method on array, which would win, or is there something to stop this?

Thanks

Answer 1

I assume you are talking about redefining methods, not overriding them, right? If two libraries overrode the same method in two different subclasses, there wouldn’t be any problem.

If two or more libraries redefine the same method, then whichever one happens to be loaded last wins. In fact, this is actually no different than just one library redefining a method: the Ruby interpreter provides an implementation of Array#<< for you, and if you redefine it, your definition wins, simply because it came later.

The best way to stop this is simple: don’t run around screwing with existing methods. And don’t use libraries that do. The -w commandline flag to enable warnings is very helpful there, since at least in Ruby 1.9.2 it prints a warning if methods get redefined.

In Ruby 2.0, there will probably be some kind of mechanism to isolate method (re-)definitions into some kind of namespace. I wouldn’t hold my breath, though: these so-called selector namespaces have been talked about in the Ruby community for almost 10 years now, and in the Smalltalk community even longer than that, and AFAIK nobody has ever produced a working implementation or even a working design for Ruby. A newer idea is the idea of Classboxes.