Before starting, I’m not asking about standard coding practice or “etiquette.” My question is more from curiosity with the internals of PHP. My research so far mostly seems to find people confused about scope in PHP.
Does re-using variables come with any benefit/detriment in PHP, either in memory or speed? For science.
Say you are sequentially accessing multiple files throughout a script.
- Scenario A: your handles each have a variable, $file1, $file2, $file3, etc.
- Scenario B: your handles all reuse the variable $fp
Will this theoretical scenario require respectively resource intensive scripts to matter? Will B allow garbage collection to get rid of the old handles while A won’t? Will optimization through Zend make this a non-issue either way?
There is not a cut & dry answer to this question. Optimization and performance will depend heavily on your particular codebase, the platform it runs on, what else is running on the server, and more.
To start with your scenarios are too vague to provide an adequate answer. However, to touch on some of the prior comments/concerns…
PHP does not have very well defined rules for garbage collection. In THEORY scenario A will release the memory when a function exits thanks to garbage collection. In reality this rarely happens. There are a number of triggers that will cause garbage collection to release that memory, but behind the scenes the actual low-level free() and mallocs() are not cut & dry. If you watch your memory stack closely you will find that after a function exit the memory space for $file1, $file2, $file3 will remain. Sometimes until the entire application exits.
Your application construction will also determine which is faster, creating a new entry in the symbol table for $file1, $file2, $file3 or re-using $fp over & over. Re-using $fp, again IN THEORY, would typically mean the memory space does not need to be re-allocated and a new symbol table entry and corresponding management object does not need to be re-created. However this is not always the case. Sometimes re-using $fp actually can be slower because a destroy needs to be called first, then re-creating the object. In some corner cases it may be faster to just create a new $file1, $file2, $file3 on the iterative process and let garbage collection happen all-at-once.
So, the bottom line of all this….
You need to analyze and test your own apps in their native environment to learn how things behave in YOUR playground. It is rarely an “always do this” or “never do that” scenario.