Question

Consider the following function:

user> (defn first-args [& args]
            (args 0))
#'user/first-args
user> (first-args 1 2 3) ;=> clojure.lang.ArraySeq cannot be cast to clojure.lang.IFn

Why is the argument list a clojure.lang.ArraySeq and not something much more common like a PersistentVector? Or why doesn’t ArraySeq implement IFn? Performance reasons? Seems like you have to know the underlying implementation of things a bit while doing Clojure. Feel free to enlighten me.

PS: this question is not about “is this idiomatic or not?” Just asking why this is like it is.

Answer 1

(defn first-args [& args]
  (first args))

(apply first-args (range)) 
;=> 0

You can apply a function to an infinite argument sequence, consuming items only as needed. If & args were required to be a vector (or anything more concrete than an ISeq), this would be impossible.

As for why seqs aren’t callable: it would encourage using them in a way that performs very poorly.