Question

Executing the command:

./program < input.txt

with the following code checking:

string input;
while(cin) {
  getline(cin, input);
}

The above code seems to generate an extra getline() call where input is empty. This happens regardless of whether or not there’s a \n on the last line of input.txt.

Answer 1

@Jacob had the correct solution but deleted his answer for some reason. Here’s what’s going on in your loop:

1. cin is checked for any of the failure bits (BADBIT, FAILBIT)
2. cin reports no problem because nothing has yet been read from the file.
3. getline is called which detects end of file, setting the EOF bit and FAILBIT.
4. Loop executes again from 1, except this time it exits.

You need to do something like this instead:

std::string input;
while(std::getline(std::cin, input))
{
     //Have your way with the input.
}