Question

F# Computation Expressions allow to hide the complexity of monadic syntax behind a thick layer of syntactic sugar. Is there something similar available in Scala?

I think it’s for comprehensions …

Example:

val f = for {
  a <- Future(10 / 2) // 10 / 2 = 5
  b <- Future(a + 1)  //  5 + 1 = 6
  c <- Future(a - 1)  //  5 - 1 = 4
 } yield b * c         //  6 * 4 = 24

 val result = f.get

But it doesn’t really feel right. Is there a better syntax?

for exemple in haskell you would have

    main = do fromHandle <- getAndOpenFile "Copy from: " ReadMode
          toHandle   <- getAndOpenFile "Copy to: " WriteMode 
          contents   <- hGetContents fromHandle
          hPutStr toHandle contents
          hClose toHandle
          putStr "Done."

this unlike scala doesn’t look like a foreach loops.
Scala syntax seem to have too strong coupling with List comprehension which is a distinct concept. Which prevent me from writing internal DSL (monad) that doesn’t look strange.

Answer 1

It seem like there is no such syntax available in scala and we would need to implement it ourself using the compiler plugin architecture.