Question

For what purpose I should use std::get_temporary_buffer? Standard says the following:

Obtains a pointer to storage sufficient to store up to n adjacent T objects.

I thought that the buffer will be allocated on the stack, but that is not true. According to the C++ Standard this buffer is actually not temporary. What advantages does this function have over the global function ::operator new, which doesn’t construct the objects either. Am I right that the following statements are equivalent?

int* x;
x = std::get_temporary_buffer<int>( 10 ).first;
x = static_cast<int*>( ::operator new( 10*sizeof(int) ) );

Does this function only exist for syntax sugar? Why is there temporary in its name?

---

One use case was suggested in the Dr. Dobb’s Journal, July 01, 1996 for implementing algorithms:

If no buffer can be allocated, or if it is smaller than requested, the algorithm still works correctly, It merely slows down.

Answer 1

Stroustrup says in “The C++ Programming Language” (§19.4.4, SE):

The idea is that a system may keep a number of fixed-sized buffers ready for fast allocation so that requesting space for n objects may yield space for more than n. It may also yield less, however, so one way of using get_temporary_buffer() is to optimistically ask for a lot and then use what happens to be available.
[…] Because get_temporary_buffer() is low-level and likely to be optimized for managing temporary buffers, it should not be used as an alternative to new or allocator::allocate() for obtaining longer-term storage.

He also starts the introduction to the two functions with:

Algorithms often require temporary space to perform acceptably.

… but doesn’t seem to provide a definition of temporary or longer-term anywhere.

An anecdote in “From Mathematics to Generic Programming” mentions that Stepanov provided a bogus placeholder implementation in the original STL design, however:

To his surprise, he discovered years later that all the major vendors that provide STL implementations are still using this terrible implementation […]