Question

Functional Decomposition, what is it useful for and what are its pros/cons? Where are there some worked examples of how it is used?

Answer 1

Functional Decomposition is the process of taking a complex process and breaking it down into its smaller, simpler parts.

For instance, think about using an ATM. You could decompose the process into:

1. Walk up to the ATM

2. Insert your bank card

3. Enter your pin

well…you get the point.

You can think of programming the same way. Think of the software running that ATM:

1. Code for reading the card

2. PIN verification

3. Transfer Processing

Each of which can be broken down further. Once you’ve reached the most decomposed pieces of a subsystem, you can think about how to start coding those pieces. You then compose those small parts into the greater whole. Check out this Wikipedia Article:

Decomposition (programming)

The benefit of functional decomposition is that once you start coding, you are working on the simplest components you can possibly work with for your application. Therefore developing and testing those components becomes much easier (not to mention you are better able to architect your code and project to fit your needs).

The obvious downside is the time investment. To perform functional decomposition on a complex system takes more than a trivial amount of time BEFORE coding begins.

Personally, I think that amount of time is well worth it.