Question

Given the class:

public class Foo
{
    public string Name { get; set; }
}

Is it possible to have a Foo instance created from a string through Convert.ChangeType:

Type type = typeof(Foo);
object value = "one";

value = System.Convert.ChangeType(value, type);

This is how a 3rd party API is attempting to rebuild objects. Someone mentioned this is possible with implicit operators, but from my understanding that will let me do the following, not create the object:

Foo foo = new Foo() { Name = "one" };
string fooAsString = foo;  // implicit conversion -- no cast needed

Is there a way to create the object this way? Also, I do have the ability to change the Convert.ChangeType if there is another way to do this.

Update:
The reason I am asking is because it throws and exception:

Invalid cast from ‘System.String’ to
‘JibbaJabba+Foo’.

and adding the operator did not resolve the issue.

Answer 1

According to the MSDN documentation:

For the conversion to succeed, value
must implement the IConvertible
interface, because the method simply
wraps a call to an appropriate
IConvertible method. The method
requires that conversion of value to
conversionType be supported.

Looking at the IConvertible interface, it has a ToType method. You could try that, maybe? (Disclaimer: I haven’t. It’s just a thought.)

Edit: In your case, it seems that you want to convert from a string to a Foo. Since the string type (obviously) does not define a conversion to Foo in its IConvertible implementation, I believe you’re out of luck.

---

Update: I don’t want to suggest that this is how you should always approach this sort of problem, but…

I took a look at the code for Convert.ChangeType in Reflector. It’s long; I won’t reproduce it here. But basically it’s doing as the documentation says: it only works if:

• The value parameter is a non-null instance of a type that implements IConvertible, or:
• The type of the value parameter and the conversionType parameter are the same (so: Convert.ChangeType(myFoo, typeof(Foo)) would also work, though it’d be pretty useless).

Then, it cycles through all the types supported by IConvertible (which obviously does not include any user-defined types) and ultimately uses ToType as a fallback.

So, we need to look at the string type’s implementation of ToType.

Sadly, it is one unfortunate line:

return Convert.DefaultToType(this, type, provider);

What does DefaultToType do? Exactly the same thing as ChangeType (minus the ToType fallback, obviously to avoid infinite recursion).

So this just simply isn’t going to work.

If you’re absolutely tied to this 3rd party library that’s using Convert.ChangeType behind the scenes, I would recommend contacting the library’s developer and asking them to extend their API in some way that will allow you to accomplish what you’re trying to accomplish. Some possiblities might be:

• Accepting an optional Converter<string, T> or Func<string, T> delegate parameter, as suggested by Ben Voigt in a comment.
• Accepting a TypeConverter parameter
• Accepting a parameter of some type that implements an interface like IParser<T>

Anyway, best of luck.