Home/ Questions/Q 174745
In Process

The Archive Base Latest Questions

Editorial Team
  • 0
Asked: 2026-05-11T13:34:39+00:00

Here’s a little experiment I ran in an Oracle database (10g). Aside from (Oracle’s)

  • 0

Here’s a little experiment I ran in an Oracle database (10g). Aside from (Oracle’s) implementation convenience, I can’t figure out why some insertions are accepted and others rejected.

create table sandbox(a number(10,0), b number(10,0)); create unique index sandbox_idx on sandbox(a,b);  insert into sandbox values (1,1); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (1,2); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (1,1); -- rejected  insert into sandbox values (1,null); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (2,null); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (1,null); -- rejected  insert into sandbox values (null,1); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (null,2); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (null,1); -- rejected  insert into sandbox values (null,null); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (null,null); -- accepted

Assuming that it makes sense to occasionally have some rows with some column values unknown, I can think of two possible use cases involving preventing duplicates:
1. I want to reject duplicates, but accept when any constrained column’s value is unknown.
2. I want to reject duplicates, even in cases when a constrained column’s value is unknown.

Apparently Oracle implements something different though:
3. Reject duplicates, but accept (only) when all constrained column values are unknown.

I can think of ways to make use of Oracle’s implementation to get to use case (2) — for example, have a special value for ‘unknown’, and make the columns non-nullable. But I can’t figure out how to get to use case (1).

In other words, how can I get Oracle to act like this?

create table sandbox(a number(10,0), b number(10,0)); create unique index sandbox_idx on sandbox(a,b);  insert into sandbox values (1,1); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (1,2); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (1,1); -- rejected  insert into sandbox values (1,null); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (2,null); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (1,null); -- accepted  insert into sandbox values (null,1); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (null,2); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (null,1); -- accepted  insert into sandbox values (null,null); -- accepted insert into sandbox values (null,null); -- accepted
Share

Leave an answer

You must login to add an answer.

Need An Account,

1 Answer

  1. create unique index sandbox_idx on sandbox  (case when a is null or b is null then null else a end,   case when a is null or b is null then null else b end);

    A functional index! Basically I just needed to make sure all the tuples I want to ignore (ie – accept) get translated to all nulls. Ugly, but not butt ugly. Works as desired.

    Figured it out with the help of a solution to another question: How to constrain a database table so only one row can have a particular value in a column?

    So go there and give Tony Andrews points too. 🙂

    • 0