Question

How are the Indexers are defined in List and Arrays.

List<MyStruct> lists=new List<MyStruct>(); where MyStruct is a Structure. Now Consider
MyStruct[] arr=new MyStruct[10];

arr[0] gives a reference to the first Structure item.But lists[0] gives me a copy of it.
Is there any reason why it is done like that.
Also since Int32 is structure List<Int32> list1 =new List<Int32>(); how it is possible for me to access list1[0] or assign list1[0]=5 where as it is not possible to do lists[0]._x=5

Answer 1

Although they look the same, the array indexer and list indexer are doing completely separate things.

The List<T> indexer is declared as a property with a parameter:

public T this[int index] { get; set; }

This gets compiled to get_Item and set_Item methods that are called like any other method when the parameter is accessed.

The array indexer has direct support within the CLR; there is a specific IL instruction ldelema (load element address) for getting a managed pointer to the n’th element of an array. This pointer can then be used by any of the other IL instructions that take a pointer to directly alter the thing at that address.

For example, the stfld (store field value) instruction can take a managed pointer specifying the ‘this’ instance to store the field in, or you can use the pointer to call methods directly on the thing in the array.

In C# parlance, the array indexer returns a variable, but the list indexer returns a value.