Question

How can I create a product key for my C# Application?

I need to create a product (or license) key that I update annually. Additionally I need to create one for trial versions.

Related:

• How do I best obfuscate my C# product license verification code?
• How do you protect your software from illegal distribution?

Answer 1

You can do something like create a record which contains the data you want to authenticate to the application. This could include anything you want – e.g. program features to enable, expiry date, name of the user (if you want to bind it to a user). Then encrypt that using some crypto algorithm with a fixed key or hash it. Then you just verify it within your program. One way to distribute the license file (on windows) is to provide it as a file which updates the registry (saves the user having to type it).

Beware of false sense of security though – sooner or later someone will simply patch your program to skip that check, and distribute the patched version. Or, they will work out a key that passes all checks and distribute that, or backdate the clock, etc. It doesn’t matter how convoluted you make your scheme, anything you do for this will ultimately be security through obscurity and they will always be able to this. Even if they can’t someone will, and will distribute the hacked version. Same applies even if you supply a dongle – if someone wants to, they can patch out the check for that too. Digitally signing your code won’t help, they can remove that signature, or resign it.

You can complicate matters a bit by using techniques to prevent the program running in a debugger etc, but even this is not bullet proof. So you should just make it difficult enough that an honest user will not forget to pay. Also be very careful that your scheme does not become obtrusive to paying users – it’s better to have some ripped off copies than for your paying customers not to be able to use what they have paid for.

Another option is to have an online check – just provide the user with a unique ID, and check online as to what capabilities that ID should have, and cache it for some period. All the same caveats apply though – people can get round anything like this.

Consider also the support costs of having to deal with users who have forgotten their key, etc.

edit: I just want to add, don’t invest too much time in this or think that somehow your convoluted scheme will be different and uncrackable. It won’t, and cannot be as long as people control the hardware and OS your program runs on. Developers have been trying to come up with ever more complex schemes for this, thinking that if they develop their own system for it then it will be known only to them and therefore ‘more secure’. But it really is the programming equivalent of trying to build a perpetual motion machine. 🙂