Question

How can I detect changes to a specific attribute of an NSManagedObject? In my Core Data data model, I have a Product entity that represents a product for sale. The Product entity has several attributes: price, sku, weight, numberInStock, etc. Whenever the price attribute of a Product changes, I need to perform a lengthy calculation. Consequently, I would like to know when the price attribute of any Product changes, [edit] even if that change comes from merging a context saved on another thread. What is a good way to go about doing this? I have thousands of Product objects in my store; obviously it’s not feasible to send each one an addObserver message.

I have been using NSManagedObjectContextObjectsDidChangeNotification to detect changes, but it only notifies me that a managed object has changed, not which attribute of that object has changed. I could redo the calculation whenever there’s any change to a Product, but that results in useless recalculations whenever an irrelevant attribute has changed. I’m considering making a Price entity (that only contains a price attribute) and using a to-one relationship between Product and Price. This way, I can detect changes to Price objects in order to kick off the calculation. This seems excessively kludgy to me. Is there a better way?

Update:

@railwayparade pointed out that I could use the changedValues method of NSManagedObject to determine which properties have changed for each updated object. I completely missed that method, and it would totally solve my problem if the changes weren’t being made on a background thread and merged into the main thread’s context. (See next paragraph.)

I completely missed a subtlety about the way that NSManagedObjectContextObjectsDidChangeNotification works. As far as I can tell, when a managed object context saved on another thread is merged into a context on the main thread (using a mergeChangesFromContextDidSaveNotification:), the resulting NSManagedObjectContextObjectsDidChangeNotification only contains change information about objects that are currently in the main thread’s managed object context. If a changed object isn’t in the main thread’s context, it won’t be part of the notification. It makes sense, but wasn’t what I was anticipating. Therefore, my thought of using a to-one relationship instead of an attribute in order to get more detailed change information actually requires examination of the background thread’s NSManagedObjectContextDidSaveNotification, not the main thread’s NSManagedObjectContextObjectsDidChangeNotification. Of course, it would be much smarter to simply use the changedValues method of NSManagedObject as @railwayparade helpfully pointed out. However, I’m still left with the problem that the change notification from the merge on the main thread won’t necessarily contain all of the changes made on the background thread.

Answer 1

This type of circumstance is where you need a custom NSManagedObject subclass. You need the subclass because you are adding a behavior, reacting to a price change, to the managed object.

In this case, you would override the accessor for the price attribute. Create a custom subclass using the popup menu in the data model editor. Then select the price attribute and choose ‘Copy Obj-C 2.0 Implementation to the Clipboard`. It will give you a lot of stuff but the key bit will look like this:

- (void)setPrice:(NSNumber *)value 
{
    [self willChangeValueForKey:@"price"];
    [self setPrimitivePrice:value];
    [self didChangeValueForKey:@"price"];
}

Just add the code to deal with the price change and you are done. Anytime a specific product’s price changes, the code will run.