Question

How do I avoid needing to repeat validation rules on both my ViewModels and business/domain objects?

For example I can use DataAnnotation attributes on my ViewModel, and this will give me client and server side validation in my MVC web app. But this ViewModel will then generally be mapped to a business/domain object and given to a service preform some business logic, meaning validation will have to happen again, often with the same or simular rules. Is there anyway round this?

Answer 1

I think what you’re describing is normal and acceptable. Consider your UI and data annotation as the friendly UI validation that is capable of showing users immediately any validation problems with the data entered.

I would consider your Business/Domain object’s validation to be the complete validation, not just validating values but enforcing business rules (i.e. – Add Item to Cart –>Is the Item in Stock?)

Then there is always back end validation that is often enforced by the database (i.e. Allowing Nulls in a column). Unless your database allows nulls in all fields, your actually performing validation in more than just the two places you mentioned, and this I think is a good thing.

I think the bottom line is that you probably want your Business/Domain objects to enforce all validation, and your client side and back end validation to simply enforce the most basic.

Hope that helps.