Question

I am developing a Online Exam Application where I have a question master table which contains a field ( name : qtype ) containing the data for the type of question. A question type can be either of following three types :

1. single
2. multiple
3. desc

The application is generating a random question paper from this master table by using the following query :

select * from mst_question where test_id = 1 ORDER BY RAND() LIMIT 25

This generates a random questionnaire of 25 questions for my Online Exam Application.

So far Its working good…

Now, I need to implement a feature in my application where the 25 randomly generated questions ( or whatever number – this will depend on the test id ) will always have a FIXED mix of the different types of questions available in the master question table ( mst_question ) for every randomly generated questionnaire set.

Say, if master question table is having 108 questions for a particular test id and all the three types of questions are in the db for this test , it will provide same number of different types questions for each random query !! I have written the following sql query to find out the percentage of each type of question in the master question table.

So far i have tried this and came up with this sql query :

select qtype,count(*) as qtypetotal,(select count(*) from mst_question where test_id = 1) as totalqtype,round((count(*)/(select count(*) from mst_question where test_id = 1)*100),2) as qtypepercentage from mst_question where test_id = 1 group by qtype

The output of above query is :

qtype       qtypetotal  totalqtype  qtypepercentage  
desc        24      108     22.22 %  
multiple    34      108     31.48 %  
single      50      108     46.30 %  

I need to form a sql query which will give me 25 randomly generated questions where 22.22% of 25 questions should be desc type , 31.48 % of 25 questions should be multiple type and remaining 46.30 % of 25 questions should be single type.

I am stuck ……. Pls advise…

Thanks in advance 🙂

Thanks @MikeBrant…. I have generated the dynamic sql which is definitely the way i wanted… just one issue now…. if i execute this sql query :

select qtype,round(25*(count(*)/(select count(*) from mst_question where test_id = 1))) as numquests from mst_question where test_id = 1 group by qtype

I am getting the following results :

“desc” “6”
“multiple” “8”
“single” “12”

and based on the above query i generate this dynamic query :

$dynamicsql[] =  "(SELECT * FROM mst_question WHERE test_id = 1 AND qtype = '".trim($rstype->qtype)."' ORDER BY RAND() LIMIT ".$rstype->numquests.")";

$finalsql = implode(" UNION ALL ",$dynamicsql)." ORDER BY RAND()";

I want to generate a total of 25 random questions but the sum of these qtypes is 26 !!! and i am getting a question extra 🙁

Answer 1

I would probably just use a UNION here:

    (SELECT * FROM mst_question
    WHERE test_id = 1 AND qtype = 'desc'
    ORDER BY RAND() LIMIT X)
UNION ALL
    (SELECT * FROM mst_question
    WHERE test_id = 1 AND qtype = 'multiple'
    ORDER BY RAND() LIMIT Y)
UNION ALL
    (SELECT * FROM mst_question
    WHERE test_id = 1 AND qtype = 'single'
    ORDER BY RAND() LIMIT Z)
ORDER BY RAND()

You can use a query like you posed on your original question to get the values for X, Y, and Z to be used.