Question

I am developing a project in C++. I realised that my program is not OO.

I have a main.cpp, and several headers for different purposes. Each header is basically a collection of related functions with some global variables to retain data. I also have a windowing.h for managing windows. This contains the winMain() and winProc(). It calls the functions that resides in my main.cpp when events happen (like clicking a button) or when it needs information (like ‘how big to make this window?’). These functions are declared in a seperate .h file included into windowing.h.

Is it worth changing this to be OO? Is it worth the work. Is there any better way I can construct the program without too many changes?

All feedback welcome, thankyou for taking the time to read this.

Answer 1

No, I think if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.

Any windowing system is inherently OO to a degree. You have a handle to a window managed by the OS, and you can perform certain operations on it. Whether you use window->resize() or resize(window) is immaterial. There is clearly no value in such syntactic rearrangement.

However, as the application grows, you will likely find that many windows are mostly similar and subtly different. The best implementation is boilerplate basic functionality with special functions attached. And the way to do that is with a base class and polymorphism.

So, if you can refactor the program to be more elegant with OO, go for it. If it grows into the OO paradigm with natural evolution, follow best practices and let it be so. But don’t just try to be buzzword-compliant.