Question

I am developing an application for iPhone and one part of it deals with a list of currencies and daily exchange rates. I am using SQLite to store all these rates.

Now I came to the part where I want to make the update part of my database with the new exchange rates.

The first thought was make a request to a server with a specific date and to read back an XML containing something like:

<date value="2010-10-04">
  <currency name="EUR" rate="xxx" />
  <currency name="USD" rate="yyy" />
  <currency name="GBP" rate="zzz" />
........
</date>
<date value="2010-10-05">
  <currency name="EUR" rate="xxx" />
  <currency name="USD" rate="yyy" />
  <currency name="GBP" rate="zzz" />
........
</date>

But now I was thinking isn’t it better to make my own format, something like:

#|2010-10-04#EURxxx#USDyyy#GBPzzz#|2010-10-05#EURxxx#USDyyy#GBPzzz##

The separator will be #. Known that always the date takes 11 characters and starts with | and currency code takes 3 characters, I can search the rate until I will find a # sign.

Because I want to send as little data as I can I think this second approach will be better than the usual XML, even if I reduce the XML to:

<d v="2010-10-04">
  <c name="EUR" r="xxx" />
  <c name="USD" r="yyy" />
  <c name="GBP" r="zzz" />
........
</d>
<d v="2010-10-05">
  <c name="EUR" r="xxx" />
  <c name="USD" r="yyy" />
  <c name="GBP" r="zzz" />
........
</d>

What are your pro & cons for this?

Answer 1

The pros:

• As you already stated, it is shorter, faster to retrieve.
• Faster to parse as well

The cons:

• If you develop the server side and the other developer on the mobile side, then he may get confused when there are no meanings

• It is hard to scale when you have more and more attributes and if you delete or change some attributes, you have to go over all codes to change it.