I am in the process of converting a Silverlight app into a standard Web app (ie all HTML, CSS and JavaScript via jQuery 1.4.4). I’m not the most experienced when it comes to web development, so I am wondering what would be the best way to convert this custom Silverlight control into a web equivalent?

It boils down to just being a fancy radio button group. The user can click on any type, and only one type can be selected at a time. For the web equivalent, it needs to set a value that will get POSTed to the server.
For now I am just using a standard <select> tag which is of course functional and doesn’t require JavaScript (which is nice), but ultimately is not going to fly. I will place a <select> inside of a <noscript> tag to allow non-js people to still be functional.
Can anyone recommend a good approach for tackling this? Any existing plugins/controls out in the wild I could take advantage of?
(I am using ASP.NET MVC 3, but I don’t think that’s very relevant here)
I would use a <ul> and make the selections a <li>. Styling is easy enough to apply to that, and there are tons of samples online.
Place a click on the li using jQuery to disable. If you are going to disable other selections, you should also include a reset/clear type function to they can choose again in case they made a mistake.