Question

I am learning C++ and it hasn’t been an enjoyable experience (compared to Java or VBA at least). I have the following code:

//This is in a number.h file
  #pragma once
  template <class T>
  class number{
        public: 
               T value1, value2, result; 
        public: 
               T add();
               number(T value1_in, T value2_in);
  };

 //This is in a number.cpp file
   template <class T>
   number<T>::number(T value1_in, T value2_in){
              value1 = value1_in;
              value2 = value2_in;
   }

   template <class T>
   T number<T>::add(){
   result = value1 + value2; 
   return result; 
   }

 //This is in main.cpp
   #include "number.h"
   #include <iostream>
   using namespace std;

   int main(){
       int a = 2, b =3;

       number<int> n1(a,b);
       cout << n1.add();
       system("pause");
       return EXIT_SUCCESS;
  }

Which of course gives me an error. Even though I am pretty sure it should work. More specifically I get a linker error. After 3 hours of looking at this I decided to include number.cpp in main.cpp and that magically made it work. What the hell is going on? I thought I only need to include the header file (I wrote a matrix class with a bunch of linear solvers for different algorithms before this and only included header files in the whole project). Is this C++ specific or compiler specific? (I am using Dev-C++ 4.9.9.2 which has Mingw I guess)

Answer 1

You do not have to put the entire definition into the header file; don’t listen to what others tell you 🙂

That is the conventional solution, and you and I will do it quite often, but it’s not the only solution.

The other option is to simply place this line at the end of your number.cpp file, in order to force that particular template class to be instantiated and fully compiled there.

template class number<int>;

In short, there are two valid solutions. You can use this line, or you can copy the definition into the header file. Depending on context, one approach might be better than the other, but both are valid. See this answer of mine for a more comprehensive discussion of both approaches:

https://stackoverflow.com/a/8752879/146041