I am looking for ideas how a concurrent framework might be implemented for my specific architecture, using C#:
I implemented several modules/containers (implemented as classes) that are all individually to connect to a message bus. Each module either mainly produces or mainly consumes, but all modules also implement a request/reply pattern for communication between two given modules. I am very new to concurrent and asynchronous programming but essentially want to run the whole architecture in a concurrent way rather than synchronously. I would really appreciate some pointers which technology (TPL, ThreadPool, CTP, open source libraries,..) to consider for my specific use case, given the following requirements:
- The whole system only runs on a local machine (in-process, even the message bus)
- At least one module performs heavy IO (several million 16byte messages per second reads from physical drive), publishing multiple 16byte chunks to a blocking collection throughout the whole time.
- Another modules consumes from the blocking collection throughout the whole time.
- The entry point is the producer starting to publish messages, exit when the producer finishes publishing a finite set of 16byte messages.
- The only communication that circumvents the message bus is the publishing/consuming to/from the blocking collection for throughput and latency reasons. (Am happy to hear suggestions to get rid of the message bus if it is plausible)
- Other modules handle operations such as writing to an SQL database, publishing to a GUI server, connecting to APIs that communicate with outside servers.Such operations run less frequently/throttled and could potentially be run as tasks rather than utilizing a whole thread throughout running the system.
- I run on a 64bit, quad core, 16gb memory machine but ideally I would like to implement a solution that can also run on a duo core machine.
Given what I like to manage what concurrency implementation would you suggest I should focus on?
EDIT: I like to emphasize that the biggest problem I am facing is how to conveniently hook up each container/module to a thread/task pool so that each of the modules runs async while still providing full in and out communication between such modules. I am not too concerned with optimizing a single producer/consumer pattern before I have not solved hooking up all the modules to a concurrent platform that can handle the number of tasks/threads involved dynamically.
I found n-act http://code.google.com/p/n-act/ , an Actors framework for .Net which implements pretty much what I am looking for. I described in my question that I look for bigger picture framework suggestions and it looks to me that an Actor Framework solves what I need. I am not saying that the n-act library will be what I implement but it is a neat example of setting up actors that can communicate asynchronously and can run on their own threads. Message passing also supports the new C#5 async/await functionality.
Disruptor was mentioned above and also the TPL and couple other ideas and I appreciate the input, it actually really got me thinking and I spent quite a bit of time to understand what each library/framework attempts to target and what problems it tries to solve, so the input was very fruitful.
For my particular case, however, I think I believe the Actors Framework is exactly what I need because my main concern is the exchange of async data flow. Unfortunately I do not see much of the Actor model implemented in any .Net technology (yet). TPL Dataflow looks very promising but as Weismat pointed out it is not yet production ready.
If N-Act does not prove stable or usable then I will look for a custom implementation through the TPL. It’s about time anyway to fully understand all that TPL has to offer and start thinking concurrently already at the design stage rather than trying to transfer synchronous models into an asynchronous framework.
In summary, “Actor Model” was what I was looking for.