Question

I can see 2 ways of implementing let bindings. First, as known from SICP, let may be implemented as lambda function. This is convenient and simple, but taking into account the fact that each lambda (fn) is translated into separate class in JVM and the number of times let is used in average program, this seems very, very expensive.

Second, let bindings may be translated directly into local Java variables. This gives very little overhead, but storing bindings on a stack breaks language semantics: in this case creation of closures is just impossible – saved values will be destroyed just after stack unwinding.

So what is actual implementation used in Clojure? Pointing to corresponding lines in Clojure source is appreciated.

Answer 1

let-bound variables are stored as final local values on the stack.

Since they are final, they can be bound into closures if needed (this is analogous how you can use a final local variable in an anonymous inner class in Java). Under the hood, the JVM copies the value into the object that represents the closure (where it is stored as a final field). As a result, the closure still works even after the stack frame goes away.

Overall, let-bound variables are extremely low overhead, you should have no hesitation at all from using them from a performance perspective. It probably isn’t possible to do any better on the JVM.