Question

I expected A::~A() to be called in this program, but it isn’t:

#include <iostream>  struct A {   ~A() { std::cout << '~A()' << std::endl; } };  void f() {   A a;   throw 'spam'; }  int main() { f(); } 

However, if I change last line to

int main() try { f(); } catch (...) { throw; } 

then A::~A() is called.

I am compiling with ‘Microsoft (R) 32-bit C/C++ Optimizing Compiler Version 14.00.50727.762 for 80×86’ from Visual Studio 2005. Command line is cl /EHa my.cpp.

Is compiler right as usual? What does standard say on this matter?

Answer 1

The destructor is not being called because terminate() for the unhandled exception is called before the stack gets unwound.

The specific details of what the C++ spec says is outside of my knowledge, but a debug trace with gdb and g++ seems to bear this out.

According to the draft standard section 15.3 bullet 9:

 9 If no matching handler is found in a program, the function terminate()   (_except.terminate_)  is  called.  Whether or not the stack is unwound   before calling terminate() is implementation-defined.