Question

I have a class named “baseClass”.
From this class I inherit a class names “inheritedClass” (public class inheritedClass: baseClass)

The baseClass contains a public function that returns a HashSet<baseClass>. When called from the inheritedClass, the return type is obviously still HashSet<baseClass>, but I need a HashSet<inheritedClass>.

A conversion ala (HashSet<inheritedClass>)returnValue, where returnValue is of Type HashSet<baseClass> doesn’t work.

Is there a way to convert the HashSet-Type from baseClass to inheritedClass without converting each element manually?

Thanks in advance,
Frank

Answer 1

Do you really mean C# in the tags? HashMap is a Java type. Also it generally has two type parameters rather than one…

In C#, generic classes are always invariant. Some interfaces will be variant in C# 4, but very few (only those which either only use the type parameter in an output positiion, e.g. IEnumerable<T>, or only use the type parameter in an input position, e.g. IComparable<T>).

If you can provide more precise information about your situation, we’ll probably be able to help come up with a simple solution – particularly if you can use LINQ with its Cast<T>() method.

EDIT: Okay, with HashSet<T>:

HashSet<BaseType> baseSet = ...;
var derivedSet = new HashSet<DerivedType>(baseSet.Cast<DerivedType>());

Note that even with C# 4 this would be necessary because the compiler doesn’t know that every value in baseSet is an instance of DerivedType – there has to be an execution-time check. The reverse (creating a HashSet<BaseType> from a HashSet<DerivedType>) would work in C# 4.

FURTHER EDIT: If you just want to use UnionWith, that doesn’t require a HashSet<DerivedType> – it requires an IEnumerable<DerivedType>. I suggest you do:

HashSet<BaseType> baseSet = ...;
HashSet<DerivedType> derivedSet = ...;

derivedSet.UnionWith(baseSet.Cast<DerivedType>());