Question

I have a large xml file and want to get a defined number of <Cooperation> nodes from it. What’s the best way to handle this.

Currently, I’m using this code

public string FullCooperationListChunkGet(int part, int chunksize)
{
    StringBuilder output_xml = new StringBuilder();
    IEnumerable<XElement> childList = from el in xml.Elements("Cooperations").Skip(part * chunksize).Take(chunksize) select el;

    foreach (XElement x in childList.Elements())
    {
        output_xml.Append(x.ToString());
    }

    return output_xml.ToString();
}

Skip(part * chunksize).Take(chunksize) doesn’t work (seems to be only valid for the Cooperations Tag and not the Cooperation Tags)

Can somebody point me in the right direction.

Thanks,
rAyt

Edit:
The Background is this: I’m pushing these xml parts via a webservice to a Blackberry. Unfortunately, the http request size on a blackberry enterprise server is limited
to 256 kb by default.

Part of the XML File:

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8" standalone="yes"?>
<Cooperations>
  <Cooperation>
    <CooperationId>xxx</CooperationId>
    <CooperationName>xxx</CooperationName>
    <LogicalCustomers>
      <LogicalCustomer>
        <LogicalCustomerId>xxx</LogicalCustomerId>
        <LogicalCustomerName>xxx</LogicalCustomerName>
        <Customers>
          <Customer>
            <CustomerId>xxx</CustomerId>
            <CustomerName>xxx/CustomerName>
          </Customer>
          <Customer>
            <CustomerId>xxx</CustomerId>
            <CustomerName>xxx</CustomerName>
          </Customer>
        </Customers>
      </LogicalCustomer>
      <LogicalCustomer>
        <LogicalCustomerId>xxx</LogicalCustomerId>
        <LogicalCustomerName>xxx</LogicalCustomerName>
        <Customers>
          <Customer>
            <CustomerId>xxx</CustomerId>
            <CustomerName>xxx</CustomerName>
          </Customer>
          <Customer>
            <CustomerId>xxx</CustomerId>
            <CustomerName>xxx</CustomerName>
          </Customer>
        </Customers>
      </LogicalCustomer>
      <LogicalCustomer>
        <LogicalCustomerId>xxx</LogicalCustomerId>
        <LogicalCustomerName>xxx</LogicalCustomerName>
        <Customers>
          <Customer>
            <CustomerId>xxx</CustomerId>
            <CustomerName>xxx</CustomerName>
          </Customer>
        </Customers>
      </LogicalCustomer>
    </LogicalCustomers>
  </Cooperation>
  <Cooperation>
  ...

Answer 1

For using XDocument, I expect you want something like:

var qry = doc.Root.Elements("Cooperation").Skip(part*chunksize).Take(chunksize);

however, if the data is large, you might have to drop down to XmlReader instead… I’ll try to do an example… (update; 512kb probably isn’t worth it…)

The problem with your code is that you are using .Elements() here:

foreach (XElement x in childList.Elements())
{
    output_xml.Append(x.ToString());
}

Just remove that:

foreach (XElement x in childList)
{
    output_xml.Append(x.ToString());
}

For info – you are also using query syntax unnecessarily:

IEnumerable<XElement> childList = from el in xml.Elements("Cooperations")
    .Skip(part * chunksize).Take(chunksize) select el;

is 100% identical to:

IEnumerable<XElement> childList = xml.Elements("Cooperations")
    .Skip(part * chunksize).Take(chunksize);

(since the compiler ignores an obvious select, without mapping it to the Select LINQ method)