Question

I have a page that allows the user to download a dynamically-generated file. It takes a long time to generate, so I’d like to show a "waiting" indicator. The problem is, I can’t figure out how to detect when the browser has received the file so that I can hide the indicator.

I’m requesting a hidden form, which POSTs to the server, and targets a hidden iframe for its results. This is, so I don’t replace the entire browser window with the result. I listen for a "load" event on the iframe, hoping that it will fire when the download is complete.

I return a "Content-Disposition: attachment" header with the file, which causes the browser to show the "Save" dialog. But the browser doesn’t fire a "load" event in the iframe.

One approach I tried is using a multi-part response. So it would send an empty HTML file, as well as the attached downloadable file.

For example:

Content-type: multipart/x-mixed-replace;boundary="abcde"

--abcde
Content-type: text/html

--abcde
Content-type: application/vnd.fdf
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename=foo.fdf

file-content
--abcde

This works in Firefox; it receives the empty HTML file, fires the "load" event, and then shows the "Save" dialog for the downloadable file. But it fails on Internet Explorer and Safari; Internet Explorer fires the "load" event, but it doesn’t download the file, and Safari downloads the file (with the wrong name and content-type) and doesn’t fire the "load" event.

A different approach might be to call to start the file creation, poll the server until it’s ready, and then download the already-created file. But I’d rather avoid creating temporary files on the server.

What should I do?

Answer 1

One possible solution uses JavaScript on the client.

The client algorithm:

1. Generate a random unique token.
2. Submit the download request, and include the token in a GET/POST field.
3. Show the “waiting” indicator.
4. Start a timer, and every second or so, look for a cookie named “fileDownloadToken” (or whatever you decide).
5. If the cookie exists, and its value matches the token, hide the “waiting” indicator.

The server algorithm:

1. Look for the GET/POST field in the request.
2. If it has a non-empty value, drop a cookie (e.g. “fileDownloadToken”), and set its value to the token’s value.

---

Client source code (JavaScript):

function getCookie( name ) {
  var parts = document.cookie.split(name + "=");
  if (parts.length == 2) return parts.pop().split(";").shift();
}

function expireCookie( cName ) {
    document.cookie = 
        encodeURIComponent(cName) + "=deleted; expires=" + new Date( 0 ).toUTCString();
}

function setCursor( docStyle, buttonStyle ) {
    document.getElementById( "doc" ).style.cursor = docStyle;
    document.getElementById( "button-id" ).style.cursor = buttonStyle;
}

function setFormToken() {
    var downloadToken = new Date().getTime();
    document.getElementById( "downloadToken" ).value = downloadToken;
    return downloadToken;
}

var downloadTimer;
var attempts = 30;

// Prevents double-submits by waiting for a cookie from the server.
function blockResubmit() {
    var downloadToken = setFormToken();
    setCursor( "wait", "wait" );

    downloadTimer = window.setInterval( function() {
        var token = getCookie( "downloadToken" );

        if( (token == downloadToken) || (attempts == 0) ) {
            unblockSubmit();
        }

        attempts--;
    }, 1000 );
}

function unblockSubmit() {
  setCursor( "auto", "pointer" );
  window.clearInterval( downloadTimer );
  expireCookie( "downloadToken" );
  attempts = 30;
}

Example server code (PHP):

$TOKEN = "downloadToken";

// Sets a cookie so that when the download begins the browser can
// unblock the submit button (thus helping to prevent multiple clicks).
// The false parameter allows the cookie to be exposed to JavaScript.
$this->setCookieToken( $TOKEN, $_GET[ $TOKEN ], false );

$result = $this->sendFile();

Where:

public function setCookieToken(
    $cookieName, $cookieValue, $httpOnly = true, $secure = false ) {

    // See: http://stackoverflow.com/a/1459794/59087
    // See: http://shiflett.org/blog/2006/mar/server-name-versus-http-host
    // See: http://stackoverflow.com/a/3290474/59087
    setcookie(
        $cookieName,
        $cookieValue,
        2147483647,            // expires January 1, 2038
        "/",                   // your path
        $_SERVER["HTTP_HOST"], // your domain
        $secure,               // Use true over HTTPS
        $httpOnly              // Set true for $AUTH_COOKIE_NAME
    );
}