Question

I have a primary key that I don’t want to auto increment (for various reasons) and so I’m looking for a way to simply increment that field when I INSERT. By simply, I mean without stored procedures and without triggers, so just a series of SQL commands (preferably one command).

Here is what I have tried thus far:

BEGIN TRAN

INSERT INTO Table1(id, data_field)
VALUES ( (SELECT (MAX(id) + 1) FROM Table1), '[blob of data]');

COMMIT TRAN;

* Data abstracted to use generic names and identifiers

However, when executed, the command errors, saying that

“Subqueries are not allowed in this
context. only scalar expressions are
allowed”

So, how can I do this/what am I doing wrong?

---

EDIT: Since it was pointed out as a consideration, the table to be inserted into is guaranteed to have at least 1 row already.

Answer 1

You understand that you will have collisions right?

you need to do something like this and this might cause deadlocks so be very sure what you are trying to accomplish here

DECLARE @id int
BEGIN TRAN

    SELECT @id = MAX(id) + 1 FROM Table1 WITH (UPDLOCK, HOLDLOCK)
    INSERT INTO Table1(id, data_field)
    VALUES (@id ,'[blob of data]')
COMMIT TRAN

To explain the collision thing, I have provided some code

first create this table and insert one row

CREATE TABLE Table1(id int primary key not null, data_field char(100))
GO
Insert Table1 values(1,'[blob of data]')
Go

Now open up two query windows and run this at the same time

declare @i int
set @i =1
while @i < 10000
begin
BEGIN TRAN

INSERT INTO Table1(id, data_field)
SELECT MAX(id) + 1, '[blob of data]' FROM Table1

COMMIT TRAN;
set @i =@i + 1
end

You will see a bunch of these

Server: Msg 2627, Level 14, State 1, Line 7
Violation of PRIMARY KEY constraint ‘PK__Table1__3213E83F2962141D’. Cannot insert duplicate key in object ‘dbo.Table1’.
The statement has been terminated.