Home/ Questions/Q 5999361
In Process

The Archive Base Latest Questions

Editorial Team
  • 0
Asked: 2026-05-23T00:32:28+00:00

I have a problem that has been effectively reduced to a Travelling Salesman Problem

  • 0

I have a problem that has been effectively reduced to a Travelling Salesman Problem with multiple salesmen. I have a list of cities to visit from an initial location, and have to visit all cities with a limited number of salesmen.

I am trying to come up with a heuristic and was wondering if anyone could give a hand. For example, if I have 20 cities with 2 salesmen, the approach that I thought of taking is a 2 step approach. First, divide the 20 cities up randomly into 10 cities for 2 salesman each, and I’d find the tour for each as if it were independent for a few iterations. Afterwards, I’d like to either swap or assign a city to another salesman and find the tour. Effectively, it’d be a TSP and then minimum makespan problem. The problem with this is that it’d be too slow and good neighborhood generation of swapping or assigning a city is hard.

Can anyone give an advise on how I could improve the above?

EDIT:

The geo-location for each city are known, and the salesmen start and end at the same places. The goal is to minimize the max travelling time, making this sort of a minimum makespan problem. So for example, if salesman1 takes 10 hours and salesman2 takes 20 hours, the maximum travelling time would be 20 hours.

Share

Leave an answer

You must login to add an answer.

Need An Account,

1 Answer

  1. Editorial Team

    TSP is a difficult problem. Multi-TSP is probably much worse. I’m not sure you can find good solutions with ad-hoc methods like this. Have you tried meta-heuristic methods ? I’d try using the Cross Entropy method first : it shouldn’t be too hard to use it for your problem. Otherwise look for Generic Algorithms, Ant Colony Optimization, Simulated Annealing …

    See “A Tutorial on the Cross-Entropy Method” from Boer et al. They explain how to use the CE method on the TSP. A simple adaptation for your problem might be to define a different matrix for each salesman.

    You might want to assume that you only want to find the optimal partition of cities between the salesmen (and delegate the shortest tour for each salesman to a classic TSP implementation). In this case, in the Cross Entropy setting, you consider a probability for each city Xi to be in the tour of salesman A : P(Xi in A) = pi. And you work, on the space of p = (p1, … pn). (I’m not sure it will work very well, because you will have to solve many TSP problems.)

    • 0