Question

I have a series of “policy” objects which I thought would be convenient to implement as class methods on a set of policy classes. I have specified a protocol for this, and created classes to conform to (just one shown below)

@protocol Counter   
+(NSInteger) countFor: (Model *)model;
@end

@interface CurrentListCounter : NSObject <Counter> 
+(NSInteger) countFor: (Model *)model;
@end

I then have an array of the classes that conform to this protocol (like CurrentListCounter does)

+(NSArray *) availableCounters {
return [[[NSArray alloc] initWithObjects: [CurrentListCounter class], [AllListsCounter class], nil] autorelease];
}

Notice how I am using the classes like objects (and this might be my problem – in Smalltalk classes are objects like everything else – I’m not sure if they are in Objective-C?)

My exact problem is when I want to call the method when I take one of the policy objects out of the array:

id<Counter> counter = [[MyModel availableCounters] objectAtIndex: self.index];
return [counter countFor: self];

I get a warning on the return statement – it says -countFor: not found in protocol (so its assuming its an instance method where I want to call a class method). However as the objects in my array are instances of class, they are now like instance methods (or conceptually they should be).

Is there a magic way to call class methods? Or is this just a bad idea and I should just create instances of my policy objects (and not use class methods)?

Answer 1

This

id <Counter> counter = [[Model availableCounters] objectAtIndex:0];
return ( [counter countFor: nil] );

Should be

Class <Counter> counter = [[Model availableCounters] objectAtIndex:0];
return ( [counter countFor: nil] );

In the first you have an instance that conforms to <Counter>. In the second you have a class that conforms to <Counter>. The compiler warning is correct because instances that conform to <Counter> don’t respond to countFor:, only classes do.