Question

I have a SQL Server stored procedure that doesn’t give me all the results when I add in the union and the second half. The first half will give me all 6 results, using the union, I only get 5.

There are 3 patients with their own [chart number], each have 2 items that should be displayed. if the [CPTCode] is the same for both entries of a patient, only one of the two entries show up when i add the union (it gives me all 6 with the same [cptcode] without the union). The second half isn’t actually pulling any information with what i’m doing right now, but it is needed.

select      /*Patients with chart numbers*/
   B1.[chart Number],
   '0' as newPatient, 
   isnull(Lytec.[Last Name],'') as [Last Name], 
   isnull(Lytec.[First Name],'') as [First Name],
   isnull(Address.[Name],
   Lytec.[Facility Code]) as [Facility], 
   isnull(B1.DOS,'') as [DOS], 
   isnull(Ins.[Name],
   Lytec.[Primary Code]) as [Primary Code],
   isnull(B1.[CPTCode],'') as cptCode, 
   isnull(B1.[Units],'') as [Units], 
   isnull(B1.[Modifiers],'') as [Modifiers], 
   isnull(B1.[cptCodeOther],'') as [cptCodeOther],
   isnull(B1.[cptCode2],'') as cptCode2, 
   isnull(B1.[Units],'') as [Units2], 
   isnull(B1.[Modifiers2],'') as [Modifiers2], 
   isnull(B1.[cptCodeOther2],'') as [cptCodeOther2],
   'name' as ProviderName
from 
   [sandboxmr].dbo.patient Lytec
   left join [dbo].[Billing] B1 on B1.[Chart Number] = Lytec.[Chart Number]
   left join [sandboxmr].dbo.[Address] Address on Lytec.[Facility Code] = Address.[Code]
   left join [sandboxmr].dbo.[Insurance] Ins on Lytec.[Primary Code] = Ins.[Code]
where 
   b1.[userid] = 54
   and (b1.[DateSubmitted] >= convert(varchar(25),'2011-8-31',101) 
   and b1.[DateSubmitted] <= convert(varchar(25),'2011-9-22',101))

union

select      /*Patients without chart numbers*/
   cast(P.id as varchar(15)) as [chart number], 
   '1' as newPatient,  
   isnull(P.[Last Name],'') as [Last Name], 
   isnull(P.[First Name],'') as [First Name],
   isnull(Address.[Name],
   P.[Facility Code]) as [Facility], 
   isnull(IV.DOS,isnull(SV.DOS,'')) as [DOS], 
   isnull(Ins.[Name],P.[Primary_Code]) as [Primary Code],
   isnull(IV.[cptCode],isnull(SV.[cptCode],'')) as cptCode, 
   isnull(IV.[Units],isnull(SV.[Units],'')) as [Units], 
   isnull(IV.[Modifiers],isnull(SV.[Modifiers],'')) as [Modifiers],    
   isnull(IV.[cptcodeother],isnull(SV.[cptcodeother],'')) as [cptCodeOther],
   isnull(IV.[cptCode2],isnull(SV.[cptCode2],'')) as cptCode2, 
   isnull(IV.Units2,isnull(SV.Units2,'')) as [Units2], 
   isnull(IV.[Modifiers2],isnull(SV.[Modifiers2],'')) as [Modifiers2], 
   isnull(IV.[cptCodeOther2],isnull(SV.[cptCodeOther2],'')) as [cptCodeOther2],
   'Name' as ProviderName
from 
   [DNSList].[dbo].[Patient] P 
   left join [dbo].[InitialVisits] IV on p.emr_id = IV.patientid
   left join [dbo].[SubsequentVisits] SV on p.emr_id = SV.patientid
   left join [sandboxmr].dbo.[Address] Address on P.[Facility Code] = Address.[Code]
left join [sandboxmr].dbo.[Insurance] Ins on P.[Primary_Code] = Ins.[Code]
where 
   p.[userid] = 54 
   and p.[Chart Number] is null
   and (p.[DateSubmitted] >= convert(varchar(25),'2011-8-31',101) 
   and p.[DateSubmitted] <= convert(varchar(25),'2011-9-22',101))
order by 
   [Last Name]

Why does it do this, and how can I fix it? I’ve tried adding a distinct to the [cptcode] area, but it of course generates an error.

Thanks for any help you can provide!

Answer 1

UNION will eliminate duplicate rows, whether they come between the two result sets or, as in your case, within just one result set. Try using UNION ALL instead.