Question

I have an Android application that has a need to perform work in the background and on a separate thread. For my first proof-of-concept I subclassed the Application class and inside onCreate() I spawn a Thread that does the background work. This works just great. However, I just realized that in the past I’ve used a service for situations like this.

The question is, is there a reason to do work on a Thread spawned from a Service instead of a Thread spawned by Application.onCreate()? The Service is supposed to perform “background” work (it uses the UI thread unless a Thread is used, I know) that is independent of the Activity and can run while no Activity is visible. Using an Application-based thread seems to accomplish all this just as well. By not using a Service it actually removes complexity because the Activity just accesses the Application singleton. As far as I know I have no need to bind to the Service.

Will I get bit by lifecycle corner cases that using a Service would prevent? That’s the only concern I have over this approach, but otherwise I’m not sold on the benefits of a Service.

Answer 1

The difference would be if you want the thread to run in the background only when the Activity is running or if you want it to continue to run when the user leaves.

Services are capable of running in the background even when the Activity is no longer available. They are intended to be used when your app should continue to do work without any user involvement in the near future. If you run the Thread in the Service, the thread will continue to run even when the user leaves the app. This can be beneficial sometimes as the user may want you to keep downloading a really large file but doesn’t want the app to continue to run in the foreground. Then, a few hours (days, months, years) later the user can re-enter the app to read the file.

If, however, you’re using a thread that needs to constantly update the UI based on results, it may be more beneficial to launch it within the Activity since it has no real purpose to run in a Service. It also may be easier in your program for your Thread to talk to the UI if it’s in the Activity rather than the Service. (There may be some performance benefits as Android doesn’t have to handle yet another Service on it’s list, but that’s purely speculation on my part. I have no proof of it.)

NOTE: Threads created in Activities will still continue to run even when the Activity quits. However, this is merely because the app is still in memory. The Activity and it’s thread are on a higher priority to be deleted from memory than a Service thread when the Activity is no longer within view.