Question

I have inherited a project that has an awkwardly big interface declared (lets call it IDataProvider). There are methods for all aspects of the application bunched up inside the file. Not that it’s a huge problem but i’d rather have them split into smaller files with descriptive name. To refactor the interface and break it up in multiple interfaces (let’s say IVehicleProvider, IDriverProvider etc…) will require massive code refactoring, because there are a lot of classes that implement the interface. I’m thinking of two other ways of sorting things out: 1) Create multiple files for each individual aspect of the application and make the interface partial or 2) Create multiple interfaces like IVehicleProvider, IDriverProvider and have IDataProvider interface inhertit from them.

Which of the above would you rather do and why? Or if you can think of better way, please tell.

Thanks

Answer 1

This book suggests that interfaces belong, not to the provider, but rather to the client of the interface. That is, that you should define them based on their users rather than the classes that implement them. Applied to your situation, users of IDataProvider each use (probably) only a small subset of the functionality of that big interface. Pick one of those clients. Extract the subset of functionality that it uses into a new interface, and remove that functionality from IDataProvider (but if you want to let IDataProvider extend your new interface to preserve existing behavior, feel free). Repeat until done – and then get rid of IDataProvider.