Question

I have made an application in android that lets the user compress and decompress files and I used the package java.util.zip. Everything is okay. the speed, files are totally compressed and decompressed together with the directories. The only problem is that the application is not able to compress/decompress large files (greater than 1gb).

I believe the problem is the size of my buffer. Other codes that I’ve seen, the value of their buffer is 1024 or 2048 or 8192 but my value of my buffer is base on the size of the chosen file (just to make it flexible). But once the user chose a large file (with a size of >8 digits), that’s were the error comes out. I searched over the net and also here in this site but I can’t find an answer. my problem is similar to this:

To Compress a big file in a ZIP with Java

Thanks for the future help! 🙂

EDIT:

Thanks for the comments and answers. It really helped a lot. I thought BUFFER in compressing/decompressing in java means the size of file so in my program, I made the buffer size flexible (buffer size = file size). Will someone please explain how buffer works so I can understand why is it okay that BUFFER has a fixed value. Also for me to figure it out why others people is telling that it is much better if the buffer size is 8k or else. Thanks a lot! 🙂

Answer 1

If you size the buffer to the size of the file, then it means that you will have OutOfMemoryError whenever the file size is too big for memory available.

Use a normal buffer size and let it do it’s work – buffering the data in a streaming fashion, one chunk at a time, rather than all in one go.

For explanation, see for example the documentation of BufferedOutputStream:

The class implements a buffered output stream. By setting up such an
output stream, an application can write bytes to the underlying output
stream without necessarily causing a call to the underlying system for
each byte written.

So using a buffer is more efficient than non-buffered writing.

And from the write method:

Ordinarily this method stores bytes from the given array into this
stream’s buffer, flushing the buffer to the underlying output stream
as needed. If the requested length is at least as large as this
stream’s buffer, however, then this method will flush the buffer and
write the bytes directly to the underlying output stream.

Each write causes the in-memory buffer to fill up, until the buffer is full. When the buffer is full, it is flushed and cleared. If you use a very large buffer, you will cause a large amount of data to be stored in memory before flushing. If your buffer is the same size as the input file, then you are saying you need to read the whole content into memory before flushing it. Using the default buffer size is usually just fine. There will be more physical writes (flushes); you avoid exploding memory.

By allowing you to specify a specific buffer size, the API is letting you choose the right balance between memory consumption and i/o to suit your application. If you tune your application for performance, you might end up tweaking buffer size. But the default size will be reasonable for many situations.