Question

I have some code

static void Main(string[] args)
{
    int j = 0;
    for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++) 
        j = j++;
    Console.WriteLine(j);
}

Why answer is 0 ?

Answer 1

This is because of the way the ++ increment works. The order of operations is explained in this MSDN article This can be seen here (somebody please correct me if I am reading the spec on this one wrong :)):

int j = 2;
//Since these are value objects, these are two totally different objects now
int intermediateValue = j;
j = 2 + 1
//j is 3 at this point
j = intermediateValue;
//However j = 2 in the end

Since it is a value object, the two objects (j and intermediateValue) at that point are different. The old j was incremented, but because you used the same variable name, it is lost to you. I would suggest reading up on the difference of value objects versus reference objects, also.

If you had used a separate name for the variable, then you would be able to see this breakdown better.

int j = 0;
int y = j++;
Console.WriteLine(j);
Console.WriteLine(y);
//Output is 
// 1
// 0

If this were a reference object with a similar operator, then this would most likely work as expected. Especially pointing out how only a new pointer to the same reference is created.

public class ReferenceTest
{
    public int j;
}

ReferenceTest test = new ReferenceTest();
test.j = 0;
ReferenceTest test2 = test;
//test2 and test both point to the same memory location
//thus everything within them is really one and the same
test2.j++;
Console.WriteLine(test.j);
//Output: 1

Back to the original point, though 🙂

If you do the following, then you will get the expected result.

j = ++j;

This is because the increment occurs first, then the assignment.

However, ++ can be used on its own. So, I would just rewrite this as

j++;

As it simply translates into

j = j + 1;