Question

I have tried to understand dependency injection and not quite gotten it, except I have managed to pick up the understanding that it makes it hard to understand somebody else’s code. :'(

Anyway, I’m not sure how to briefly describe my problem but I will try. I am currently the sole coder working on a Java project that’s been worked on by dozens of loners over about six years. It makes heavy use of Google’s Guice library. I’m supposed to take some existing code and implement it differently; specifically, use the existing methods for password authentication and, instead of applying it to each JMenuItem in a JMenu, apply it to the whole JMenu, so that if the wrong password or no password is entered, all JMenuItems are disabled. This doesn’t happen if the password is wrong, leading me to believe the problem is in the if statement, which is a long string of dependencies in itself:
if (!ViewScanApp.getApplication().getHistoryManager().isAuthenticated())

I trace my way back through this, to find that the HistoryManager class is an interface, and there my path seems to die; there’s no code there, and it doesn’t make a reference to any other class. I have found the end of the path through random exploration of the 100-odd classes in the project, but I can’t quite seem to connect them. I cannot find where the first class I can find on the other end of this stack, AccessManagerImpl, gets called.

I could use an explanation of dependency injection that might be applicable to this situation. Thank you so much!

Answer 1

Assuming there’s no @ImplementedBy annotation on the HistoryManager interface, you’ll need to examine the Guice Module that is responsible for binding this type.

In Eclipse, there is a command to look for occurrences of a class. I’ll bet that Netbeans has something similar. Use it to look for occurrences of HistoryManager. At least one of these should occur in a class that implements com.google.inject.Module (or extends AbstractModule). You’ll likely see something like

protected void configure() {
  …
  bind(HistoryManager.class).to(HistoryManagerImpl.class);
  …
}

Or, if you like quick-and-dirty empiricism, you can throw in a println():

HistoryManager mgr = ViewScanApp.getApplication().getHistoryManager();
System.out.println("HistoryManager implementation: " + mgr.getClass());
if (!mgr.isAuthenticated())
   …

However you locate it, HistoryManagerImpl class is where you’ll want to pick up the trail.

I haven’t used it, but the Guice graphing tool might be helpful too.