Question

I have two asynchronous methods Task<int> DoInt() and Task<string> DoString(int value). I have a third asynchronous method Task<string> DoBoth(int value) whose goal is to asynchronously execute DoInt(), piping it’s output to DoString(int) and having the result be the result of DoBoth().

The important constraints are:

1. I may not have source code to DoInt() or DoString(), so I can’t
   modify them.
2. I don’t want to block at any point
3. Output (result) of one task must be passed as input to the next
4. The final output (result) is what I want to be the result of DoBoth()

The key being I already have methods that are asynchronous (i.e. return Task) and I want to pipe data from task to task, without blocking along the way, returning the final result in the initial task. I can do all the following except not blocking in the following code:

Code example:

// Two asynchronous methods from another library, i.e. can't be changed
Task<int> DoInt(); 
Task<string> DoString(int value);

Task<string> DoBoth()
{
    return DoInt().ContinueWith<string>(intTask => 
    {
        // Don't want to block here on DoString().Result
        return DoString(intTask.Result).Result; 
    });
}

Since Task<string> DoString(int) is already an asynchronous method, how do I cleanly create a non-blocking continuation to it? Effectively I want to create a continuation from an existing Task and not from a Func.

Answer 1

You can write the entire chain using TaskExtensions.Unwrap as:

Task<string> DoBoth(int value)
{
    Task<Task<string>> task = DoInt(value).ContinueWith(valueTask => 
    {
        return DoString(valueTask.Result); 
    });

    return task.Unwrap();
}

Note that this assumes that DoInt is defined as Task<int> DoInt(int value);, which differs from your description, but follows your code example.

If DoInt does not take an int argument (matching your declarations), this could become:

Task<string> DoBoth()
{
    return DoInt().ContinueWith(t => DoString(t.Result)).Unwrap();
}

---

As an extra – using C# 5 and .NET 4.5 (or the async targeting pack), you can write this as:

async Task<string> DoBoth(int value)
{
    int first = await DoInt(value);
    return await DoString(first);
}