Question

I have two SQL queries producing different results when I would expect them to produce the same result. I am trying to find the number of events that do not have a corresponding location. All locations have an event but events can also link to non-location records.

The following query produces a count of 16244, the correct value.

SELECT COUNT(DISTINCT e.event_id)   
FROM   events AS e   
WHERE  NOT EXISTS   
  (SELECT * FROM locations AS l WHERE l.event_id = e.event_id)    

The following query produces a count of 0.

SELECT COUNT(DISTINCT e.event_id) 
FROM   events AS e
WHERE  e.event_id NOT IN (SELECT  l.event_id FROM locations AS l)

The following SQL does some summaries of the data set

SELECT  'Event Count', 
        COUNT(DISTINCT event_id) 
        FROM events

UNION ALL

SELECT  'Locations Count', 
        COUNT(DISTINCT event_id) 
        FROM locations

UNION ALL

SELECT  'Event+Location Count', 
        COUNT(DISTINCT l.event_id) 
        FROM locations AS l  JOIN events AS e ON l.event_Id = e.event_id

And returns the following results

Event Count         139599
Locations Count         123355
Event+Location Count    123355

Can anyone shed any light on why the 2 initial queries do not produce the same figure.

Answer 1

You have a NULL in the subquery SELECT l.event_id FROM locations AS l so NOT IN will always evaluate to unknown and return 0 results

SELECT COUNT(DISTINCT e.event_id) 
FROM   events AS e
WHERE  e.event_id NOT IN (SELECT  l.event_id FROM locations AS l)

The reason for this behaviour can be seen from the below example.

‘x’ NOT IN (NULL,’a’,’b’)

≡ ‘x’ <> NULL and ‘x’ <> ‘a’ and ‘x’
<> ‘b’

≡ Unknown and True and True

≡ Unknown