Question

I know you can ALTER the column order in MySQL with FIRST and AFTER, but why would you want to bother? Since good queries explicitly name columns when inserting data, is there really any reason to care what order your columns are in in the table?

Answer 1

Column order had a big performance impact on some of the databases I’ve tuned, spanning Sql Server, Oracle, and MySQL. This post has good rules of thumb:

• Primary key columns first
• Foreign key columns next.
• Frequently searched columns next
• Frequently updated columns later
• Nullable columns last.
• Least used nullable columns after more frequently used nullable columns

An example for difference in performance is an Index lookup. The database engine finds a row based on some conditions in the index, and gets back a row address. Now say you are looking for SomeValue, and it’s in this table:

 SomeId int,
 SomeString varchar(100),
 SomeValue int

The engine has to guess where SomeValue starts, because SomeString has an unknown length. However, if you change the order to:

 SomeId int,
 SomeValue int,
 SomeString varchar(100)

Now the engine knows that SomeValue can be found 4 bytes after the start of the row. So column order can have a considerable performance impact.

EDIT: Sql Server 2005 stores fixed-length fields at the start of the row. And each row has a reference to the start of a varchar. This completely negates the effect I’ve listed above. So for recent databases, column order no longer has any impact.