Question

I learn Scala for some time and can’t clearly understand the usage of Option. It helps me to avoid null checks when I chain functions (according to docs). That’s clear for me 🙂

Next I see that Option can be kind of indicator for developer that null value is possible here and it must be handled. Is it true? If yes should I use Option whereever it’s possible? For example

class Racer {
    val car = new Car()
}

I have Racer class and I’m sure that car field can’t be null (because it’s constant and get a value when I create Racer instance). No need for Option here.

class Racer {
    var car = new Car()
}

Here I make it so that the car can change. And it’s possible for someone to assign null to car. Should I use Option here? If yes I notice that all my class fields are candidates for Option. And my code looks like this

class Racer {
    var car: Option[Car] = None
    var currentRace: Option[Race] = None
    var team: Option[Team] = None
    ...
}

Does it look good? For me it seems kind of Option overusing.

def foo(): Result = {
    if( something )
        new Result()
    else
        null
}

I have a method which can return null. Should I return Option instead? Should I always do it if it’s possible for method to return null?

Any thoughts about it would be helpful. Thanks in advance!

My question is similiar to Why option but I think it’s not the same. It’s more about when, not why. 🙂

Answer 1

You should avoid null as much as possible in Scala. It really only exists for interoperability with Java. So, instead of null, use Option whenever it’s possible that a function or method can return “no value”, or when it’s logically valid for a member variable to have “no value”.

With regard to your Racer example: Is a Racer really valid if it doesn’t have a car, currentRace and team? If not, then you shouldn’t make those member variables options. Don’t just make them options because it’s theoretically possible to assign them to null; do it only if logically you consider it a valid Racer object if any of those member variables has no value.

In other words, it’s best to pretend as if null doesn’t exist. The use of null in Scala code is a code smell.

def foo(): Option[Result] = if (something) Some(new Result()) else None

Note that Option has many useful methods to work with.

val opt = foo()

// You can use pattern matching
opt match {
  case Some(result) => println("The result is: " + result)
  case None         => println("There was no result!")
}

// Or use for example foreach
opt foreach { result => println("The result is: " + result) }

Also, if you want to program in the functional style, you should avoid mutable data as much as possible, which means: avoid the use of var, use val instead, use immutable collections and make your own classes immutable as much as possible.