Question

I tried to extend a list and was puzzled by having the result return with the value None. What I tried was this:

>>> a = [1,2]  
>>> b = [3,4]  
>>> a = a.extend(b)  
>>> print a  

None

I finally realized that the problem was the redundant assignment to ‘a’ at the end. So this works:

>>> a = [1,2]  
>>> b = [3,4]  
>>> a.extend(b)  
>>> print a  

[1,2,3,4]

What I don’t understand is why the first version didn’t work. The assignment to ‘a’ was redundant, but why did it break the operation?

Answer 1

Because, as you noticed, the return value of extend is None. This is common in the Python standard library; destructive operations return None, i.e. no value, so you won’t be tempted to use them as if they were pure functions. Read Guido’s explanation of this design choice.

E.g., the sort method on lists returns None as well, while the non-destructive sorted function returns a value.