Question

I understand what the double not operator does in JavaScript. I’m curious about it’s use though and whether or not a recent assertion that I made is correct.

I said that if (!!someVar) is never meaningful nor is (!!someVar && ... because both the if and the && will cause someVar to be evaluated as a boolean so the !! is superfluous.

In fact, the only time that I could think of that it would be legitimate to use the double not operator is if you wanted to do a strict comparison to another boolean value (so maybe in return value that expects true or false explicitly).

Is this correct? I started to doubt myself when I noticed jQuery 1.3.2 used both if (!!someVar) and return !!someVar && ...

Does the double not have any actual effect in these situations?

My personal opinion is that it just leads to confusion. If I see an if statement, I know it’s evaluating it as a boolean.

Answer 1

In the context of if statements I’m with you, it is completely safe because internally, the ToBoolean operation will be executed on the condition expression (see Step 3 on the spec).

But if you want to, lets say, return a boolean value from a function, you should ensure that the result will be actually boolean, for example:

function isFoo () {
  return 0 && true;
}

console.log(isFoo()); // will show zero
typeof isFoo() == "number";

In conclusion, the Boolean Logical Operators can return an operand, and not a Boolean result necessarily:

The Logical AND operator (&&), will return the value of the second operand if the first is truly:

true && "foo"; // "foo"

And it will return the value of the first operand if it is by itself falsy:

NaN && "anything"; // NaN
0 && "anything"; // 0

On the other hand, the Logical OR operator (||) will return the value of the second operand, if the first one is falsy:

false || "bar"; // "bar"

And it will return the value of the first operand if it is by itself non-falsy:

"foo" || "anything"; // "foo"

Maybe it’s worth mentioning that the falsy values are: null, undefined, NaN, 0, zero-length string, and of course false.

Anything else (that is not falsy, a Boolean object or a Boolean value), evaluated in boolean context, will return true.