Question

I use the following MySQL to return a list of posts and their corresponding comments.

    SELECT  *
    FROM    forum_qa
            JOIN user_profiles
              ON user_id = forum_qa_author_id
            LEFT JOIN (SELECT forum_cm_id,
                              forum_cm_author_id,
                              forum_qa_id_fk,
                              forum_cm_text,
                        FROM  forum_cm
                        JOIN  user_profiles
                          ON  user_id = forum_cm_author_id) AS c
              ON forum_qa_id = c.forum_qa_id_fk
    WHERE   forum_qa_parent_id  = $forum_qa_id

If I run

    $data['num_answers'] = $query->num_rows();

This allows me to get the number of returned rows and pass the array to my controller and view.

But this is returning all rows (posts + comments). So if 1 post has 10 comments, it returns 10.

How could I have this query count only the number of posts (ie, returning 1) not including the subquery?

Each post has a unique id saved in forum_qa.forum_qa_id

Each comment has a unique id saved in forum_cm.forum_cm_id.

Thanks for helping — will post more code if needed.

Answer 1

Not the fastest, but you are not restricted in using GROUP BY:

SELECT  *, 
  (SELECT COUNT(*) FROM forum_qa WHERE forum_qa_parent_id  = $forum_qa_id) Cnt
    FROM    forum_qa
            JOIN user_profiles
              ON user_id = forum_qa_author_id
            LEFT JOIN (SELECT forum_cm_id,
                              forum_cm_author_id,
                              forum_qa_id_fk,
                              forum_cm_text,
                        FROM  forum_cm
                        JOIN  user_profiles
                          ON  user_id = forum_cm_author_id) AS c
              ON forum_qa_id = c.forum_qa_id_fk
    WHERE   forum_qa_parent_id  = $forum_qa_id