Question

I was reading thourg this example (link)…

From the description, this seems paradox to me:

When implementing a table view cell,
there’s a tension between optimal
scrolling performance and optimal
edit/reordering performance. You
should typically use subviews in the
cell’s content view.

When you have an edit or reordering
control, using subviews makes the
implementation easier, and the
animations perform better because
UIKit doesn’t have to redraw during
animations.

Conclusion: Subviews are faster because UIKit must not redraw during animations. So when scrolling, it must not call -drawRect: all the time. Right?

And then, the paradoxon:

If the content is complex, however
(more than about three subviews),
scrolling performance may suffer. If
this becomes a problem, you can
instead draw directly in a subview of
the table view cell’s content view.

Conclusion: Prefer -drawRect: to draw directly on the table view cell. Better scroll performance for complex cells. Better than a lot of subviews.

So, well then. What’s true? Subviews or -drawRect: Which is the better one?

In my case I would have like 12 subviews per cell. Are they actually just trying to say this? “If you have only up to 3 subviews, go with them. But if you have much more, use -drawRect: and draw directly on the cell.”. But then: Why not always prefer -drawRect: then?

Answer 1

You could sum it up as Display only Vs Functional. If your cells are tasked simply with displaying data that doesn’t change much and remains static, draw it. If your cells are tasked with being functional, can change position or are manipulated by the user (or you have custom animation), look at using subviews.

There isn’t really a hard and fast rule to this. Your use case is good measurement on which approach is best. With 12 subviews i’d instantly lean towards custom drawing for the speed benefits.

Why not always prefer -drawRect: then?

You get quite a few things for free by using subviews. Animations are ‘easier’. Using a UIImageView to display an image gives you highlighting for free, for example. It really depends on what your cell is tasked with.