Question

I would like to share with you an issue I’m having while trying to process some attributes from XML elements in C++ with Boost libraries (version 1.52.0). Given the following code:

#define ATTR_SET ".<xmlattr>"
#define XML_PATH1 "./pets.xml"

#include <iostream>
#include <string>
#include <boost/foreach.hpp>
#include <boost/property_tree/ptree.hpp>
#include <boost/property_tree/xml_parser.hpp>

using namespace std;
using namespace boost;
using namespace boost::property_tree;

const ptree& empty_ptree(){
    static ptree t;
    return t;
}

int main() {
    ptree tree;
    read_xml(XML_PATH1, tree);
    const ptree & formats = tree.get_child("pets", empty_ptree());
    BOOST_FOREACH(const ptree::value_type & f, formats){
        string at = f.first + ATTR_SET;
        const ptree & attributes = formats.get_child(at, empty_ptree());
        cout << "Extracting attributes from " << at << ":" << endl;
        BOOST_FOREACH(const ptree::value_type &v, attributes){
            cout << "First: " << v.first.data() << " Second: " << v.second.data() << endl;
        }
    }
}

Let’s say I have the following XML structure:

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<pets>
    <cat name="Garfield" weight="4Kg">
        <somestuff/>
    </cat>
    <dog name="Milu" weight="7Kg">
        <somestuff/>
    </dog>
    <bird name="Tweety" weight="0.1Kg">
        <somestuff/>
    </bird>
</pets>

Therefore, the console output I’ll get will be the next:

Extracting attributes from cat.<xmlattr>:
First: name Second: Garfield
First: weight Second: 4Kg
Extracting attributes from dog.<xmlattr>:
First: name Second: Milu
First: weight Second: 7Kg
Extracting attributes from bird.<xmlattr>:
First: name Second: Tweety
First: weight Second: 0.1Kg

However, if I decide to use a common structure for every single element laying down from the root node (in order to identify them from their specific attributes), the result will completely change. This may be the XML file in such case:

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<pets>
    <pet type="cat" name="Garfield" weight="4Kg">
        <somestuff/>
    </pet>
    <pet type="dog" name="Milu" weight="7Kg">
        <somestuff/>
    </pet>
    <pet type="bird" name="Tweety" weight="0.1Kg">
        <somestuff/>
    </pet>
</pets>

And the output would be the following:

Extracting attributes from pet.<xmlattr>:
First: type Second: cat
First: name Second: Garfield
First: weight Second: 4Kg
Extracting attributes from pet.<xmlattr>:
First: type Second: cat
First: name Second: Garfield
First: weight Second: 4Kg
Extracting attributes from pet.<xmlattr>:
First: type Second: cat
First: name Second: Garfield
First: weight Second: 4Kg

It seems the number of elements hanging from the root node is being properly recognized since three sets of attributes have been printed. Nevertheless, all of them refer to the attributes of the very first element…

I’m not an expert in C++ and really new to Boost, so this might be something I’m missing with respect to hash mapping processing or so… Any advice will be much appreciated.

Answer 1

The problem with your program is located in this line:

const ptree & attributes = formats.get_child(at, empty_ptree());

With this line you are asking to get the child pet.<xmlattr> from pets and you do this 3 times independently of whichever f you are traversing. Following this article I’d guess that what you need to use is:

const ptree & attributes = f.second.get_child("<xmlattr>", empty_ptree());

The full code, that works with both your xml files, is:

#define ATTR_SET ".<xmlattr>"
#define XML_PATH1 "./pets.xml"

#include <iostream>
#include <string>
#include <boost/foreach.hpp>
#include <boost/property_tree/ptree.hpp>
#include <boost/property_tree/xml_parser.hpp>

using namespace std;
using namespace boost;
using namespace boost::property_tree;

const ptree& empty_ptree(){
    static ptree t;
    return t;
}

int main() {
    ptree tree;
    read_xml(XML_PATH1, tree);
    const ptree & formats = tree.get_child("pets", empty_ptree());
    BOOST_FOREACH(const ptree::value_type & f, formats){
        string at = f.first + ATTR_SET;
        const ptree & attributes = f.second.get_child("<xmlattr>", empty_ptree());
        cout << "Extracting attributes from " << at << ":" << endl;
        BOOST_FOREACH(const ptree::value_type &v, attributes){
            cout << "First: " << v.first.data() << " Second: " << v.second.data() << endl;
        }
    }
}