If I have an app that consists of multiple layers, defined as multiple projects in a solution, is it ok to have a layer reference the layer directly above/below it? Or, should one use dependency injection to eliminate this need?
I am building on a more specific questions that I asked here, but I would like more general advice.
How would I go about setting up a project like this in VS2010? Would I need a third project to house the DI stuff?(I am using Ninject)
EDIT: example
Here is an example of my two layers. first layer has an IUnitOfWork Interface and the second layer has a class that implements said interface. Setup in this manner, the project will not build unless layer 2 has a references to layer 1. How can I avoid this? Or, should I not even be worried about references and leave it alone since the layers are adjacent to one another?
Layer 1
public interface IUnitOfWork
{
void Save();
}
Layer 2
public DataContext : IUnitOfWork
{
public void Save()
{
SaveChanged(); //...
}
}
General advise is to decouple layers by interfaces and use Dependency Injection and IoC containers for great level of flexibility whilst maintaining an Application.
But sometimes it could be an overkill for small applications, so to give you a more specific example you have to provide at least description of the application and layers which it has.
Regarding DI stuff, I would suggest to encapsulate it in a separate assembly.
See great article by Martin Fowler Inversion of Control Containers and the Dependency Injection pattern
EDIT: Answer to comments regarding interface
Only one way to get rid of such coupling is to store common interfaces/classes in a separate assembly. In your case create separate assembly and put here is
IUnitOfWorkinterface.EDIT: Ninject projects reference
There are 147 Ninject projects, I would suggest to download and investigate most interesting from your point of view: Ninject projects