If you are developing an extension for one of the mozilla applications (e.g. Firefox, Thunderbird, etc.) you define a extension id in the install.rdf.
If for some reason you need to know the extension id e.g. to retrieve the extension dir in local file system (1) or if you want to send it to a webservice (useage statistic) etc. it would be nice to get it from the install.rdf in favour to have it hardcoded in your javascript code.
But how to access the extension id from within my extension?
1) example code:
var extId = "myspecialthunderbirdextid@mydomain.com";
var filename = "install.rdf";
var file = extManager.getInstallLocation(extId).getItemFile(extId, filename);
var fullPathToFile = file.path;
I’m fairly sure the ‘hard-coded ID’ should never change throughout the lifetime of an extension. That’s the entire purpose of the ID: it’s unique to that extension, permanently. Just store it as a constant and use that constant in your libraries. There’s nothing wrong with that.
What IS bad practice is using the install.rdf, which exists for the sole purpose of… well, installing. Once the extension is developed, the install.rdf file’s state is irrelevant and could well be inconsistent.
“An Install Manifest is the file an Add-on Manager-enabled XUL application uses to determine information about an add-on as it is being installed” [1]
To give it an analogy, it’s like accessing the memory of a deleted object from an overflow. That object still exists in memory but it’s not logically longer relevant and using its data is a really, really bad idea.
[1] https://developer.mozilla.org/en/install_manifests