I’m a CS master student, and next semester I will have to start working on my thesis. I’ve had trouble coming up with a thesis idea, but I decided it will be related to Computer Graphics as I’m passionate about game development and wish to work as a professional game programmer one day.
Unfortunately I’m kinda new to the field of 3D Computer Graphics, I took an undergraduate course on the subject and hope to take an advanced course next semester, and I’m already reading a variety of books and articles to learn more. Still, my supervisor thinks its better if I come up with a general thesis idea now and then spend time learning about it in preparation for doing my thesis proposal. My supervisor has supplied me with some good ideas but I’d rather do something more interesting on my own, which hopefully has to do with games and gives me more opportunities to learn more about the field. I don’t care if it’s already been done, for me the thesis is more of an opportunity to learn about things in depth and to do substantial work on my own.
I don’t know much about GPU programming and I’m still learning about shaders and languages like CUDA. One idea I had is to program an entire game (or as much as possible) on the GPU, including all the game logic, AI, and tests. This is inspired by reading papers on GPGPU and questions like this one I don’t know how feasible that is with my knowledge, and my supervisor doesn’t know a lot about recent GPUs. I’m sure with time I will be able to answer this question on my own, but it’d be handy if I could know the answer in advance so I could also consider other ideas.
So, if you’ve got this far, my question: Using only shaders or something like CUDA, can you make a full, simple 3D game that exploits the raw power and parallelism of GPUs? Or am I missing some limitation or difference between GPUs and CPUs that will always make a large portion of my code bound to CPU? I’ve read about physics engines running on the GPU, so why not everything else?
DISCLAIMER: I’ve done a PhD, but have never supervised a student of my own, so take all of what I’m about to say with a grain of salt!
I think trying to force as much of a game as possible onto a GPU is a great way to start off your project, but eventually the point of your work should be: “There’s this thing that’s an important part of many games, but in it’s present state doesn’t fit well on a GPU: here is how I modified it so it would fit well“.
For instance, fortran mentioned that AI algorithms are a problem because they tend to rely on recursion. True, but, this is not necessarily a deal-breaker: the art of converting recursive algorithms into an iterative form is looked upon favorably by the academic community, and would form a nice center-piece for your thesis.
However, as a masters student, you haven’t got much time so you would really need to identify the kernel of interest very quickly. I would not bother trying to get the whole game to actually fit onto the GPU as part of the outcome of your masters: I would treat it as an exercise just to see which part won’t fit, and then focus on that part alone.
But be careful with your choice of supervisor. If your supervisor doesn’t have any relevant experience, you should pick someone else who does.