Question

im having a View with a ComboBox bound to my viewModel property.
Everything works fine but i actually want to reuse my View and need to
update the controls with a given value. Setting the property wont update the visual UI
even to event is fired and everyting looks good.

Everything works accept the ComboBox visual UI.

Tips?!

XAML control

<telerik:RadComboBox 
            ItemTemplate="{StaticResource SelectUserComboBoxTemplate}"
            SelectedItem="{Binding Path=SelectedUser, Mode=TwoWay,
            UpdateSourceTrigger=PropertyChanged}" 
            ItemsSource="{Binding Path=C_users}" 
            telerik:TextSearch.TextPath="displayName"
            Name="radComboBox1" 
            Margin="14,12,0,0" 
            Height="31" 
            VerticalAlignment="Top" 
            HorizontalAlignment="Left" 
            Width="253" 
            TextSearchMode="Contains"
            IsEditable="True"
            OpenDropDownOnFocus="True" 
            IsFilteringEnabled="True"
            >
    </telerik:RadComboBox>

The overloaded constructor that sets the values

    public TicketControlTabViewModel(ticket t)
    {
        activeTicket = t;
        SelectedUser = customerServiceClient.getUser(t.customer_users.id);
        MetaString = t.meta;
        Description = t.description;
        ActiveId = t.id.ToString();
        Selected_priority = t.priority;
        SelectedStatus = t.status;
        this.RefreshC_users();
        this.RefreshSupportDepartments();
        this.RefreshSupportUsers();
    }

The property in my ViewModel

    private customer_users selectedUser { get; set; }
    public customer_users SelectedUser
    {

        get {
            return this.selectedUser;
            }
        set {
              if (value != null){
              this.selectedUser = value;
              this.UpdateCustomerDepartment(value);
              this.OnPropertyChanged("SelectedUser");
              SaveTicket();
              }

            }
    }

Answer 1

By default, WPF compares the SelectedItem by reference, not by value. That means if the SelectedItem isn’t the exact same object in memory as the item in your ItemsSource, then the comparisom will return false and the item will not get selected.

For example, this will probably not work

MyCollection = new ObservableCollection<User>(DAL.GetUsers());
SelectedUser = DAL.GetUser(1);

however this would:

MyCollection = new ObservableCollection<User>(DAL.GetUsers());
SelectedUser = MyCollection.FirstOrDefault(p => p.Id == 1);

That’s because the 2nd example sets the SelectedUser to an item that actually exists in MyCollection, while the 1st example might not. Even if the data is the same, they reference different objects in memory.

If your selected item doesn’t reference the same item in memory as your ItemsSource item, then either use SelectedValue and SelectedValuePath to bind your ComboBox’s default selection, or overwrite the .Equals() method of your class to return true if the data in the objects being compared is the same.

public override bool Equals(object obj)
{
    if (obj == null || !(obj == MyClass))
        return false; 

    return ((MyClass)obj).Id == this.Id);
}